Metablogs

Guides / Guide 3 of 6 · Getting started

Blogging platforms compared: WordPress, Ghost, Substack and static sites

Every platform trades control for convenience in a different place. Here is where each one draws the line, and which kind of blogger each suits.

4 min read

Blue "Meta" notes point out the writing move the next paragraph makes.

Which blogging platform is best depends on how you work and what the blog is for. Someone who wants to write on a phone between meetings needs a different tool from someone who enjoys tweaking templates on a Sunday afternoon.

This comparison sticks to things that change your day-to-day life as a blogger: how much setup you face, what you can customise, how you could earn from it, and how hard it is to leave. Prices change often, so check each platform’s current pricing page before you decide.

The question that matters most: can you leave?

Before features, check the exit. Ask two things of any platform:

  1. Can I use my own domain? If the answer is no, or only on a paid plan you don’t intend to buy, every link anyone gives you points to someone else’s address.
  2. Can I export everything? Posts, images, and ideally your email subscriber list, in a format another platform can import.

All of the platforms below pass both tests in some form. Plenty of free blogging services over the years did not, and their users lost their archives when the service closed. Keep that history in mind when something new and shiny appears.

Self-hosted WordPress

WordPress powers a very large share of the web, and the self-hosted version (from WordPress.org) is free software you install on your own hosting.

Good for: bloggers who want full control, a huge choice of themes and plugins, and the ability to turn the blog into a shop, membership site or directory later.

The trade-off: you are the system administrator. Updates, backups, security and speed are your problem, or the problem of the hosting company you pay. Plugins are powerful, but each one is code someone else wrote, and stacking twenty of them is how WordPress sites get slow and fragile.

Earning: anything goes. Ads, affiliate links, digital products, memberships, all through plugins or third-party services.

WordPress.com

This is the hosted service run by Automattic. You get the WordPress editor without running a server.

Good for: people who like WordPress but don’t want to maintain it.

The trade-off: the cheaper plans limit plugins and custom themes. Check which plan unlocks the features you care about before assuming WordPress.com equals WordPress.

Ghost

Ghost is an open-source publishing platform built around writing and email newsletters. You can host it yourself or pay for Ghost(Pro), the official hosted version.

Good for: writers who want a clean editor and built-in newsletters and paid memberships, without assembling those from plugins.

The trade-off: fewer themes and integrations than WordPress, and a narrower focus. It is built for publishing; if you later want a shop or a directory, you’ll be bolting things on.

Earning: paid subscriptions and memberships are built in, and Ghost takes no percentage of that revenue (you pay for hosting, plus the payment processor’s fees). Ads and affiliate links work as on any site.

Substack

Substack is a newsletter platform first and a blog second. Every post can go to subscribers’ inboxes and also appears on a web page.

Good for: writers whose readers prefer email, and anyone who wants to start in minutes with zero setup.

The trade-off: limited design control and a platform-shaped look. Substack takes a percentage of paid subscriptions, so the cost scales with your success. Its discovery features can bring readers, but they are also a reason your audience may feel like they belong to the platform as much as to you.

Earning: paid subscriptions mainly.

Medium

Medium hosts your writing on its own domain and has its own reader network and partner programme.

Good for: testing whether people respond to your writing before you build a site.

The trade-off: you are writing on someone else’s property. Treat it as a place to republish, with a link back to your own site, rather than as the home of your archive.

Static site generators

Tools such as Astro, Hugo, Eleventy and Jekyll turn plain text files into a fast website you can host cheaply or for free on services such as Cloudflare Pages, Netlify or GitHub Pages. This site is built that way.

Good for: people comfortable with Git and a code editor who want speed, low cost and total ownership.

The trade-off: no admin dashboard by default. Writing means editing Markdown files. Comments, newsletters and search need extra services. If the phrase “commit and push” makes you uneasy, this is not the place to start.

Earning: anything you can add with a script or a link: ads, affiliates, products sold through a checkout service.

A quick way to decide

Answer these in order and stop at the first yes.

  1. Do you mostly want to send a newsletter? Start with Substack or Ghost.
  2. Do you want paid memberships built in and a clean writing tool? Ghost.
  3. Do you want to build more than a blog later (shop, directory, courses)? Self-hosted WordPress.
  4. Do you want WordPress without the maintenance? WordPress.com on a plan that fits.
  5. Are you a developer who likes owning every file? A static site generator.
  6. Still unsure? Write five posts on Medium or Substack first. You’ll learn what you need before you pick a long-term home.

Switching later

People switch platforms all the time, and it is less painful than it sounds if you prepared. Use your own domain from day one. Keep your post URLs simple (/blog/post-name/ ages better than URLs with dates and categories in them). When you move, set up permanent 301 redirects from every old URL to its new address so links and search rankings follow you.

With a home for the blog chosen, the next job is the writing itself: how to write a blog post people finish reading.